Ethics rules for AI legal intake agents

An intake agent talks to people on the worst day of their year. It must not give legal advice, promise results or pressure anyone to sign. Some outreach also waits on the calendar: 30 days after an accident in Florida, 45 after an air crash. The firm's lawyers answer for all of it under Rule 5.3.

Intake chat · Car crashPreview: coming soon

A law firm's intake agent is replying to someone hurt in a rear-end crash two days ago.

I'm the firm's AI assistant, not a lawyer. You definitely have a strong case, and it's worth at least $150,000. Don't talk to their insurer. Sign our agreement now so we can start.

What Cerata will check

  • Failed: No legal advice or predicted results from a nonlawyer assistant
  • Failed: No pressure to sign before a lawyer has reviewed the matter
  • Passed: Says it's the firm's AI assistant, not a lawyer
Block

Don't send this reply. Valuing a case and telling someone what to do is legal advice, and a promised result can mislead under Rule 7.1.Fix: “I'm sorry you're dealing with this. I can't give legal advice, but an attorney will review what you've shared and call you today. Please keep any letters from the insurance company.”

Coverage

  • Coming soon:legal advice limits, solicitation waiting periods and prospective-client duties

BlockAgent's reply

You definitely have a strong case worth at least $150,000. Sign now.

Would clearAfter the fix

An attorney will review your situation and call you today. Here's what to keep.

The laws that apply

Most of these rules bind lawyers, through each state's version of the ABA Model Rules. An intake agent is the firm's nonlawyer assistant, so its words are the firm's.

  1. Unauthorized practice of lawe.g. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 6125, 6126

    Coming soon

    Only licensed lawyers may practice law, and each state defines it its own way. Applying law to someone's facts and telling them what to do is the core of it, whoever does it.

    Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code 6125 on California Legislative Information (opens in a new tab)
  2. Rule 5.3: nonlawyer assistanceABA Model Rule 5.3

    Coming soon

    Lawyers with managerial authority must make reasonable efforts to ensure a nonlawyer's conduct is compatible with the lawyer's professional obligations. ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies this to generative AI tools.

    ABA Model Rule 5.3 (opens in a new tab)
  3. Rules 7.1 to 7.3: advertising and solicitationABA Model Rules 7.1, 7.2, 7.3

    Coming soon

    No false or misleading claims about the firm's services, including unjustified expectations of results. No live person-to-person solicitation for pay of someone who didn't ask, with narrow exceptions. States add their own rules.

    ABA Model Rule 7.3 (opens in a new tab)
  4. Rule 1.18: prospective clientsABA Model Rule 1.18

    Coming soon

    What a person tells the firm about a possible matter is confidential even if the firm never takes the case, and can create conflicts. Ask only what the firm needs to check conflicts.

    ABA Model Rule 1.18 (opens in a new tab)
  5. State bar waiting periodse.g. Rules Regulating The Florida Bar 4-7.18(b)

    Coming soon

    Some state bars ban targeted solicitation soon after an accident. In Florida, no written solicitation to the person or a relative for 30 days, and later emails must start the subject with “Advertisement”.

    Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, Chapter 4 (opens in a new tab)
  6. Air crash: 45-day bar49 U.S.C. § 1136(g)(2)

    Coming soon

    After an airline accident, no lawyer, lawyer's agent or potential party may make unsolicited contact with victims or their relatives about an injury or wrongful-death claim before the 45th day.

    49 U.S.C. § 1136 on Cornell LII (opens in a new tab)

Intake replies, checked

Intake agents want to reassure. These are the kinds of replies a legal check would catch before they reach someone who is hurt or scared.

  • We'll get you a settlement within a monthFlag

    A promised result can mislead. Say an attorney will review it.

  • You should sue the landlord in small claimsBlock

    Applying law to their facts is legal advice. Route to a lawyer.

  • Email a Florida crash victim 12 days after the crashBlock

    Florida bars written solicitation for 30 days. Wait until day 31 and start the subject with “Advertisement”.

  • An attorney will call you by 4 p.m. todayClear

    Accurate, no advice, and sets a clear next step.

Illustrative. Solicitation rules and waiting periods vary by state.

What can go wrong

For a law firm, the cost is the license as much as the fine, and an intake agent says the same thing to everyone who asks.

Up to $1,000

fine and up to a year in county jail for practicing law in California without being an active licensee, a misdemeanor.

Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 6126(a)
Discipline

for the supervising lawyers when a nonlawyer assistant's conduct would break the rules and they ordered it, ratified it or failed to fix it in time.

ABA Model Rule 5.3(c)

Figures from the statutes. Penalties and discipline rules differ by state. General information, not legal advice.

How Cerata fits

When these checks arrive, they'll use the same step as every other Cerata check: one call before each reply, call or text, with holds routed to a lawyer.

  1. Before replying or reaching out, your agent sends the draft, the channel and how the person came in.
  2. Cerata will check for legal advice, promised results, solicitation limits, waiting periods and what to ask.
  3. Your agent follows the answer. A hold goes to the supervising lawyer, and the receipt records it.
What your agent gets backPOST /v1/preflight
→ 200 OK
{
  "decision": "block",
  "fixes": [{ "text": "Remove the case value, the instructions and the push to sign. Say an attorney will review the matter and call today." }],
  "receipt": "eyJhbGciOiJFZERTQSJ9…"
}

Questions

More in the glossary and on the blog.

Can an AI intake agent give legal advice?

No. Giving legal advice is the practice of law, which only licensed lawyers may do. An intake agent can gather facts, explain next steps and set appointments. The supervising lawyers answer for it under Rule 5.3.

How soon after an accident can a law firm contact the victim?

It depends on where and how. Florida bars written solicitation about an accident for 30 days, and federal law bars unsolicited contact about an air-crash claim for 45 days. Rule 7.3 separately limits live calls to people who didn't ask.

Can an AI agent call accident victims for a law firm?

That is risky. Rule 7.3 bans live person-to-person solicitation for pay, with narrow exceptions, and whether an AI voice counts is unsettled. The TCPA also requires consent for artificial-voice calls to cell phones. Cerata would hold these for a lawyer. See artificial voice.

Is information from a website chat confidential?

Often, yes. Rule 1.18 protects what prospective clients share even if the firm never takes the case. So intake agents should ask only what's needed, and the firm should know where those conversations are stored.

Does Cerata check legal intake today?

Not yet. Legal intake checks are coming soon. Today Cerata checks sales calls and texts (federal rules and Florida), marketing email and rental listings (federal rules). New York City job posts are next.

Start with the checks that are live today.

Legal intake checks will arrive through the same step your agent already uses.