Insurance compliance for AI agents
AI agents now quote policies, answer coverage questions and reply to claims. Unfair claims laws bar misstating what a policy covers. Licensing laws cover anyone who sells, solicits or negotiates insurance. The TCPA covers sales calls and texts, and CMS adds rules for Medicare plans. Cerata checks insurance sales calls and texts today; claims, licensing and Medicare checks are coming soon.
Thanks for your claim. Your policy doesn't cover water damage, so we're unable to pay for the repairs.
What Cerata will check
- Failed: Matches the policy wording: sudden pipe bursts are covered
- Failed: Gives the policy basis for any denial
- Needs a person: A coverage decision someone with claim authority should make
A claims adjuster reviews this reply. The policy covers sudden pipe bursts. Telling a claimant otherwise misstates the policy, which California's unfair claims law forbids.Fix: quote the policy's water-damage section, say what is covered and what still needs inspection, and let an adjuster make the call.
Coverage
- Checked today:sales calls and texts, federal rules and Florida
- Coming soon:claims handling, licensing and Medicare marketing
HoldAgent's draft
Claim denied: your policy doesn't cover water damage.
Would clearAfter review
Burst pipe covered under the dwelling coverage. An adjuster books an inspection for Thursday.
The laws that apply
Insurance is regulated state by state, and most states start from the same NAIC model laws. None of them has an exception for words an agent wrote.
Unfair claims settlement practicesCal. Ins. Code § 790.03(h); NAIC Model Act #900
Coming soonInsurers may not misrepresent policy provisions to claimants, must answer claim communications promptly and must explain the basis for a denial. In California, a violation is knowing conduct or a frequent business practice.
Cal. Ins. Code 790.03 on California Legislative Information (opens in a new tab)Producer licensingNAIC Producer Licensing Model Act § 3
Coming soonSelling, soliciting or negotiating insurance needs a license, and negotiating includes advising a buyer on a particular policy's terms. An agent that recommends a policy should run under a licensed producer.
NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act (PDF) (opens in a new tab)NAIC Model Bulletin on insurers' use of AINAIC, adopted Dec. 4, 2023
Coming soonInsurers using AI should keep a written program that guards against harm to consumers, vendor AI included. AI-made decisions must still meet unfair trade and claims laws. About half the states have adopted it.
NAIC Model Bulletin (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Colorado SB21-169C.R.S. § 10-3-1104.9
Coming soonBars insurers from using external consumer data, algorithms or models that unfairly discriminate by race, sex, disability or other protected traits, in marketing, underwriting, pricing or claims. Division rules require testing.
SB21-169 on the Colorado General Assembly site (opens in a new tab)Medicare Advantage marketing42 CFR §§ 422.2263(a), 422.2267(e)(41)
Coming soonPlans may begin marketing next year's offerings on October 1. Third-party marketers must give a set disclaimer, naming how many organizations and plans they represent, before discussing benefits. See Medicare agents.
42 CFR 422.2267 on eCFR (opens in a new tab)Telephone Consumer Protection Act47 U.S.C. § 227; 47 CFR § 64.1200
Checked todayInsurance sales calls and texts follow the same consent, calling-hours and do-not-call rules as any other telemarketing. Cerata checks these today, for insurance outreach too. See TCPA.
47 U.S.C. § 227 on Cornell LII (opens in a new tab)
Sell, solicit, negotiate: where the line falls
Licensing and claims laws turn on what is said, not on who or what says it. These are the kinds of replies a legal check would sort.
This policy has a $1,000 deductible and covers sudden pipe bursts.
ClearAccurate, taken from the policy, no recommendation.
HoldYou should switch to the Gold plan, it's the better deal for youA recommendation about a particular policy can be negotiation. Hand off to a licensed producer.
A licensed agent can go through your options. Want a call tomorrow at 10 a.m.?
ClearHands off. The call itself is checked for consent and local time.
Illustrative. What counts as licensed activity, and which exceptions apply, varies by state.
What can go wrong
A claims agent answers the same question the same way for every policyholder, so one wrong reading of a policy can become a business practice.
civil penalty in California for an unfair claims or trade practice, or up to $10,000 per act if willful. The commissioner decides what counts as one act.
Cal. Ins. Code § 790.035for each call or text that breaks the TCPA consent rules. Courts can triple the $500 when the violation is willful or knowing.
47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(3)Figures from the statutes. Each state sets its own penalties for unfair claims practices and unlicensed activity. General information, not legal advice.
How Cerata fits
Sales calls and texts are checked today; claims, licensing and Medicare checks will use the same step, with claim decisions routed to the adjusters you choose.
- Before a reply or quote goes out, your agent sends the draft and the policy it relies on.
- Cerata will check the statement against the policy, the claims rules and the licensing line for that state.
- Coverage decisions wait for a person on your team, and the receipt records who decided.
→ 200 OK
{
"decision": "hold",
"fixes": [{ "text": "The policy covers sudden pipe bursts. Quote the coverage section and route the decision to a claims adjuster." }],
"receipt": "eyJhbGciOiJFZERTQSJ9…"
}
Do insurance laws apply to AI agents?
Yes. Unfair claims and trade practice laws regulate what the insurer does and says, whoever drafts it. The NAIC's 2023 model bulletin says decisions made with AI must meet the same laws, and expects insurers to oversee AI tools they get from vendors.
Does an AI insurance agent need a license?
Licensing laws cover any person who sells, solicits or negotiates insurance. An AI agent that recommends a policy or discusses its terms with a buyer may be doing that work, so run it under a licensed producer and hand off where state law requires. The rules vary by state; ask your counsel.
What is Colorado SB21-169?
A 2021 Colorado law that bars insurers from using external consumer data, algorithms and predictive models in ways that unfairly discriminate against protected groups, and requires them to show how they test for it.
Does Cerata check insurance agents today?
Partly. Insurance sales calls and texts are covered by Cerata's TCPA checks today. Claims, licensing, Medicare marketing and AI governance checks are coming soon.
Start with the checks that are live today.
Insurance sales calls and texts are checked today. Claims and licensing checks will arrive through the same step.